Nikkor 85mm f/1.8D vs 85mm f/1.8G

cameras, Lenses, nikon, opinons, thoughts, photography, pictures, street, Travel

Same focal length. Same max aperture. Very different intent.

The 85mm f/1.8GD vs 85mm f/1.8G comparison is way more interesting than people think—this isn’t just “older vs newer,” it’s two different philosophies of portrait lenses.

1. Design Philosophy (This Is the Core Difference)

85mm f/1.8D

  • Designed in the film-era mindset
  • Optimized for:
    • Speed
    • Compactness
    • High micro-contrast
  • Assumes the photographer:
    • Focuses manually with intent
    • Accepts character over perfection

👉 The D lens does not apologize for optical flaws. It uses them.

85mm f/1.8G

  • Designed in the digital-era mindset
  • Optimized for:
    • Resolution
    • Smoothness
    • Consistency across the frame
  • Assumes:
    • High-resolution sensors
    • Autofocus accuracy matters
    • Images will be scrutinized at 100%

👉 The G lens is corrective and controlled.

2. Optical Performance

Sharpness

Aperture85mm f/1.8D85mm f/1.8G
f/1.8Sharp center, soft edgesSharper center, cleaner edges
f/2.8Very sharpExtremely sharp
f/4–5.6ExcellentClinically excellent
  • The G is objectively sharper, especially wide open and toward the edges.
  • The D has bite—center sharpness with strong micro-contrast that feels punchy, especially on faces.

📌 On modern high-MP sensors, the G holds together better technically.

Contrast & Rendering

  • D lens
    • Higher micro-contrast
    • Harder transitions
    • More “snap”
    • Faces look more sculpted, sometimes harsher
  • G lens
    • Smoother tonal roll-off
    • Lower micro-contrast
    • More forgiving on skin
    • Easier to grade in post

👉 This is why some people say the D looks “3D” and the G looks “creamy.”

3. Bokeh & Out-of-Focus Rendering

85mm f/1.8D

  • Nervous bokeh in busy backgrounds
  • Cat’s-eye shapes near edges
  • Double lines in specular highlights
  • Can feel edgy or distracting

⚠️ Not a “safe” bokeh lens.

85mm f/1.8G

  • Significantly smoother background blur
  • More rounded aperture blades
  • Better correction of spherical aberration
  • Backgrounds dissolve rather than vibrate

👉 For environmental portraits or street portraits, the G is far more predictable.

4. Autofocus & Handling

Autofocus

  • D: Screw-drive AF
    • Fast on pro bodies
    • Noisy
    • Inaccurate at f/1.8
  • G: Silent Wave Motor (AF-S)
    • Quieter
    • More accurate
    • Better for modern DSLRs

If you’re shooting moving subjects or candid portraits, the G wins decisively.

Build & Ergonomics

Aspect1.8D1.8G
SizeSmallerLarger
WeightLighterHeavier
BuildSolid, simpleModern composite
Focus ringBetter manual feelAdequate, not special

The D feels mechanical.
The G feels engineered.

5. Compatibility & Practical Reality

85mm f/1.8D

  • ❌ No AF on entry-level Nikon bodies
  • ✔️ Excellent on D700, D3, D4, Df
  • ✔️ Gorgeous on film bodies
  • ✔️ Very cheap on the used market

85mm f/1.8G

  • ✔️ Full AF on all Nikon DSLRs
  • ✔️ Designed for high-resolution sensors
  • ✔️ Better resale value
  • ❌ Less character

6. Character vs Control (The Honest Take)

Choose the 85mm f/1.8D if:

  • You value rendering over perfection
  • You shoot:
    • Street portraits
    • Gritty documentary
    • Black & white
  • You like lenses that argue back
  • You enjoy working around flaws

👉 This lens has teeth.

Choose the 85mm f/1.8G if:

  • You need:
    • Reliable AF
    • Smooth skin tones
    • Predictable results
  • You shoot:
    • Editorial portraits
    • Commercial work
    • Color-heavy projects
  • You want files that are easy to finish in post

👉 This lens is quietly competent.

7. One-Line Verdict (Brutally Honest)

  • 85mm f/1.8D:
    A portrait lens with attitude and consequences.
  • 85mm f/1.8G:
    A portrait lens that stays out of the way.

Leave a comment